【Report】Europe and Asia in a Changing International Order
The Ritsumeikan International Symposium “Europe and Asia in a Changing International Order” took place on Thursday, November 5, 2026, at Ritsumeikan University. The symposium was co-hosted by the JSPS KAKENHI Research Project (Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B), 23K25489; Principal Investigator: Prof. Midori Okabe) and the Institute of International Relations and Area Studies (IIRAS), Ritsumeikan University. After opening remarks by Keiichi Shirato, Director of IIRAS, the program had two panels and a concluding session. The first panel covered EU diplomacy and Europe’s relations with Asia, the second covered migration governance, and the concluding session brought together economic security, migration, and diplomacy.
Professor Tomoya Kuroda (Senshu University) presented on EU–Asia relations and, drawing on archival research, examined whether closer ties with Asia are possible as European integration faces a “polycrisis”. He traced the establishment of ASEM in the 1990s, the Asian financial crisis of 1997, which exposed ASEM’s limits, and the rise of the G20 during the crisis of multilateralism between 1997 and 2009. He then discussed the shift from the “Asia-Pacific” to the “Indo-Pacific” concept, EU–ASEAN relations, and the question of whether EU–Japan relations are in a “golden age”. He concluded that from both the EU and ASEAN perspectives, the evolution of EU–Asia relations has been neither a success nor a failure, but remains one of the most important issues in their politics. He also suggested that the “Trump shock” may serve as a catalyst for closer relations between Europe and Asia.
Professor Kauzhige Kobayashi (Ritsumeikan University) focused on new developments in Russia–Europe relations. He argued that Russian diplomacy has turned toward the Global South, where many states now use their ties with Russia as a strategic leverage to improve their bargaining position vis-à-vis the EU. He also argued that while Europe focuses on Ukraine, China has gained a competitive advantage by absorbing cheap Russian energy and expanding its global infrastructure. Finally, he warned that replacing Russian energy increases costs and weakens Europe's competitiveness, and that sanctions against Russia risk becoming “self-sanctions”.
Professor Yoichiro Sato (Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University) presented on developments in the FOIP and its links with the EU. He described how FOIP has developed around four pillars: security, democratic values, economic prosperity, and a rules-based order. He pointed to a tension between values-based diplomacy and realist compromises and the securitization of free trade. He placed the EU in FOIP’s widening network of partnerships, including the Japan–EU Strategic Partnership Agreement.
Professor Fiona Adamson (SOAS University of London) examined how migration diplomacy is increasingly used as a tool of migration management, and how this affects migrants’ rights and human rights more broadly. She showed how states link migration to other interests, including the economy, public diplomacy, security and soft power. She highlighted the two sides of European migration diplomacy. On the one hand, it focuses on control: the European Commission’s 2026 strategy prioritizes preventing irregular migration and securing returns, often through transactional agreements that harm migrants’ rights. On the other hand, it seeks to attract workers: like Japan, Europe needs labor, and EU member states have concluded around 120 bilateral labor agreements. She concluded that the key challenge is to build interstate cooperation that protects human rights at a time when liberal norms are eroding.
Professor Eiko Thielemann (London School of Economics and Political Science) examined why refugee responsibilities among EU states remain so unequal, and why EU responsibility-sharing policies have not been more effective. He compared the Yugoslav, Syrian, and Ukrainian crises. Drawing on the literature on migration pull factors and on collective action and free-riding in the provision of public goods, he argued that the disparities in responsibilities call for substantive cooperation, through both policy harmonization, despite its limitations, and effective burden-sharing and redistributive policies. He then discussed whether solidarity in the EU has been symbolic or substantive, distinguishing between market-based, voluntary, and mandatory forms of sharing. He concluded that the EU’s response to the Ukrainian crisis was more substantive than its responses to the Syrian and Yugoslav crises, that it led to fairer outcomes, and that states should learn from it.
Professor Midori Okabe (Sophia University) explored the internal–external nexus in EU migration diplomacy. She began with immigration control as an issue of international relations and the development of the post-war migration regime, and then showed how EU migration governance has moved from policy harmonization to summit-based transactional diplomacy. She argued that the foundations of EU migration diplomacy are changing on two levels. Externally, the EU is becoming less attractive as a basis for cooperation, and migration management is turning into a bargaining resource. Internally, member states are increasingly unwilling to accept the unequal burdens of the Schengen/Dublin system, and national interests are carrying more weight. She closed by calling for further research, drawing on negotiation theories, into how these internal and external dynamics shape each other.
Professor Kazuto Suzuki (The University of Tokyo) opened the concluding session with a resentation on economic security and the EU. He described geopolitics as the use of economic dvantages, such as the indispensability of goods and markets, as national power to influence ther countries. He argued that the weakening of the WTO and the growing weaponization of the conomy are creating an international order based on power rather than rules. As a result, the ules-based order that the EU has long pursued no longer protects it. He questioned whether the EU can become a geoeconomic power. Although market indispensability is the strongest form of geoeconomic power, the EU lacks strategic indispensability: despite its strengths upstream, it lacks the capacity to use them as leverage, and it is held back by divisions among the Commission, member states and industry, as well as by the lack of common geoeconomic objectives. At the same time, social unrest and fiscal pressures are pushing it toward protectionism. The session closed with a panel discussion among all speakers
During the Q&A sessions, the audience raised engaging questions on Japan’s FOIP strategy, Russian foreign policy, the utility of sanctions against Russia, Ukrainian migrants in the EU, international cooperation on migration, and responsibility sharing in migration governance.
