【Report】Eastern Cousins of Westphalian States? Territory and Sovereignty in Early Modern Japan
Eastern Cousins of Westphalian States? Territory and Sovereignty in Early Modern Japan
On November 12, 2026, Naosuke Mukoyama, Associate Professor at the University of Tokyo, gave a talk on his ongoing book project on state formation in early modern Japan.
Prof. Mukoyama began by explaining the conventional narrative of state formation: sovereign states emerged in Europe after the 1648 Treaty of Westphalia and spread to the rest of the world through colonialism. He explained that this narrative rests on two assumptions: a) the European experience of state formation is unique and b) the process of European state formation is universal. The University of Tokyo professor emphasized that his book project aims to challenge these assumptions by showing that state formation also occurred in early modern Japan and that the state formation process differs from that of European states, despite producing a similar outcome.
After explaining the general historical background of early modern Japan, Prof. Mukoyama clarified that his focus is on the formation of feudal domains as sovereign states rather than considering Japan as a whole.
The University of Tokyo professor then explained the process of border formation in early modern Japan. He explained that borders were mostly delineated in a bottom-up process—from the level of villages to that of domains, which were then accepted by the Tokugawa Shogunate.
Next, Prof. Mukoyama explained the state formation process in early modern Japan. Contrary to the conventional Westphalian view that states are formed through fighting or preparing for war, he argued that peace contributed to the formation of sovereign states; peace settled borders and led to the development of state institutions and the centralization of state power.
In conclusion, Prof. Mukoyama outlined the unfinished sections of the book project and explained avenues for future research.
During the Q&A, audience members asked many questions—including those about the process of border formation, the role of war-making in state formation, and the conditions that lead to state formation.
